How to Fish.ing

Quest item decision tool

Before you sell it, check it.

Some catches are cash. Others are the key to the next island. Search the thing in your hands before the grill, shop or ocean gets it.

Dockside item check

What are you holding?

CurrentPatch 1.1.32026-10-02
15 items found
quest inputKeep this

Beer Can

Take it straight to the Lighthouse Keeper. He gives you the Empty Beer Can you need for Spider Crab.

Where
Lighthouse
Part of
Who Stole My Beer
What you get next
Empty Beer Can
How to get it

Buy it at the Lighthouse, then give it to the Lighthouse Keeper.

Hand it toLighthouse Keeper

boss baitUse this

Empty Beer Can

Put it on your rod and cast for Spider Crab. This is the bait that starts the fight.

Where
Lighthouse
Part of
Who Stole My Beer
What you get next
Spider Crab encounter
How to get it

Receive it from the Lighthouse Keeper after handing over the Beer Can.

boss dropKeep this

Spider Crab Remains

Pick up the remains and take them back to the Lighthouse Keeper. That hand-in gets you the Boat Keys.

Where
Lighthouse
Part of
Who Stole My Beer
What you get next
Boat Keys and the Forest route
How to get it

Pick up the distinctive remains after defeating Spider Crab.

Hand it toLighthouse Keeper

quest inputKeep this

Leeches (3)

Collect all three and give them to the woman on Forest Island. She turns them into Giant Piranha bait.

Where
Island 2 · Forest
Part of
Giant Piranha bait quest
What you get next
Modified Leech
How to get it

Collect three small ground pickups on Island 2 near the quest giver.

Hand it toForest quest giver

boss baitUse this

Modified Leech

Put it on your rod and cast in the Forest lake to start the Giant Piranha fight.

Where
Island 2 · Forest
Part of
Giant Piranha bait quest
What you get next
Giant Piranha encounter
How to get it

Receive it after giving three Leeches to the Forest quest giver.

boss dropKeep this

Giant Piranha Skeleton

Carry the skeleton back to the woman who gave you the Modified Leech. This unlocks Island 3.

Where
Island 2 · Forest
Part of
Giant Piranha story gate
What you get next
Island 3 coordinates
How to get it

Pick it up after defeating Giant Piranha.

Hand it toForest quest giver

quest inputKeep this

Endangered Fish

Give the marked fish to the Tourist. Needlefish, Bowlfish and Seahorse can all count when they carry the Endangered tag.

Where
Island 3 · Desert
Part of
Vacation / Pufferfish bait route
What you get next
Carrot boss bait
How to get it

Catch a creature carrying the Endangered marker with the Standard Lure.

Hand it toTourist

boss baitUse this

Carrot

Put the Carrot on your rod and cast for Pufferfish. It is boss bait, not food.

Where
Island 3 · Desert
Part of
Vacation / Pufferfish bait route
What you get next
Pufferfish encounter
How to get it

Receive it from the Tourist after handing in an Endangered fish.

boss dropKeep this

Pufferfish Fin

Grab the fin after the fight and take it back to the Tourist. This opens the route to Island 4.

Where
Island 3 · Desert
Part of
Pufferfish story gate
What you get next
Island 4 coordinates
How to get it

Pick up the quest drop after defeating Pufferfish.

Hand it toTourist

creatureKeep this

Blue Shark

Carry your first Blue Shark to the Grillmaster. Selling or cooking it means catching another one.

Where
Island 3 · Desert
Part of
Grillmaster
What you get next
The grill and the cooking value route
How to get it

Catch it with the Standard Boss Lure.

Hand it toGrillmaster

creatureKeep this

Tuna

Keep one Tuna whole. Leave it for the Albatross to take, then get ready for the fight.

Where
Island 4 · Rocks
Part of
Terrorizing Bird
What you get next
Albatross encounter
How to get it

Catch it with the Professional Boss Lure.

boss dropKeep this

Albatross Head

Pick up the head and return it to the Island 4 quest giver. This unlocks the Volcano route.

Where
Island 4 · Rocks
Part of
Terrorizing Bird
What you get next
Island 5 coordinates
How to get it

Pick it up after defeating the Albatross.

Hand it toIsland 4 quest giver

boss baitUse this

Fish Bucket

Put the Fish Bucket on your rod and use it to catch the Bowhead Whale.

Where
Island 5 · Volcano
Part of
Final island scientist route
What you get next
Bowhead Whale encounter
How to get it

Receive it from the scientist after completing the five-creature hand-in.

Hand it toScientist

creatureKeep this

Bowhead Whale

Keep the whale whole and carry it to the crater. Throwing it in starts the final boss fight.

Where
Island 5 · Volcano
Part of
Final boss route
What you get next
Mutated Bowhead Whale encounter
How to get it

Catch it with the Fish Bucket.

boss dropKeep this

Mutated Bowhead Whale Tail

Take the tail to the final quest giver, finish the hand-in, then use the escape boat.

Where
Island 5 · Volcano
Part of
Final boss route
What you get next
Game completion and escape
How to get it

Pick it up after defeating Mutated Bowhead Whale.

Hand it toFinal quest giver

One rule saves the run

Finish the hand-in before you cash out.

Boss bait, story drops and marked quest catches move the game forward. If this page says Keep this, take it to the named NPC before you sell, cook or leave it behind.

The documented five-stage route remains in this tool. Patch 1.1.0 added mini-islands; their exact route steps are pending independent cross-checks. Current game version: 1.1.3.

Open full walkthrough →See source policy →